|
OPHTHALMOLOGY TIMES
THE GLAUCOMA ANGLE
COLUMN #19
100 YEARS OF PROGRESS IN GLAUCOMA
Introduction - Robert Ritch, MD
The third glaucoma subspecialty day at the Annual Meeting of the
American Academy of Ophthalmology in Chicago this year was entitled
‘100 Years of Progress In Glaucoma: Celebrating Our Heritage and
Looking to the Future.’ The meeting provided a comprehensive review
of many aspects of glaucoma diagnosis and therapy from the time of von
Graefe to the present.
Chicago 1996: Third Glaucoma Subspecialty Day Looks
to the Past to Give Perspective on the Future
Richard N. Gordon, MD
In his introductory remarks, Dr. M. Bruce Shields pointed out how
poorly understood glaucoma was 100 years ago. Perimetry was limited to
Bjerrum’s campimeter. The only available medical therapy consisted
of pilocarpine and eserine, and surgical procedures were crude and
fraught with complications. Gonioscopy had not yet been devised, so
the broad classification of glaucoma into open-angle and closed-angle
mechanisms was not appreciated. From this point, the expert panel of
speakers added an historical perspective to the current thinking in
glaucoma and to its future trends.
The morning session was devoted to reviewing our understanding of
the etiology and pathophysiology of glaucoma. Some speakers
entertained, others presented historical overviews of their topic,
some personal and some didactic. Several speakers were particularly
relevant and thought provoking. Dr. David Epstein described how the
aqueous humor outflow pathways were discovered. He also talked about
the debate as to the site at which resistance to aqueous humor outflow
through the trabecular meshwork occurs. Most investigators agree that
the primary site of resistance to conventional outflow is the
juxtacanalicular trabecular tissue (JCT). This resistance is thought
to be caused by either the deposition of a plaque-like material,
altered glycosaminoglycans, or reduced surface area of aqueous
channels near the JCT. Alternatively, the structure of the inner wall
of Schlemm's canal may produce resistance through “giant vacuoles”
in the wall of the canal (which have been demonstrated using electron
microscopy) and by the overlying endothelial cells. Outflow resistance
may be decreased by agents that modulate the inner wall endothelial
cell cytoskeleton or cell adhesion, such as ethacrynic acid, EDTA, or
cytochalasin B. These agents can separate the endothelial cells and
promote outflow.
Dr. Harry Quigley discussed the mechanisms of glaucomatous optic
nerve atrophy. Recent research indicates that ganglion cell death in
glaucoma probably occurs via apoptosis, which is a genetically
programmed mode of cell death (‘cell suicide’). For instance, one
means of potential glaucomatous damage to retinal ganglion cell axons
consists of interrupted axoplasmic transport in both directions, in
turn leading to a decrease in the concentration of growth factors
reaching those portions of the ganglion cell where they exert their
activity. This relative reduction in growth factor availability is
thought to initiate the apoptotic cascade. One possible direction in
glaucoma therapy may be the prevention of apoptosis by replacing these
growth factors pharmacologically (a form of ‘neuroprotective’
therapy). The question remains as to how seemingly different entities
like idiopathic (primary) open-angle glaucoma and normal-tension
glaucoma cause axoplasmic flow stasis. Dr. Quigley feels the answer
may lie in the structure of the lamina cribrosa. Elastin is one
component of the lamina which protects it from backward excavation.
High IOP can damage elastin in the lamina and facilitate its backward
stretching, in turn leading to poor capillary blood flow, which
inhibits axonal transport. In normal-tension glaucoma, optic nerve
vascular nutrition may be inherently compromised, leading to
axoplasmic transport stasis, but this factor alone would not explain
the excavation of the optic nerve head that occurs. Dr. Quigley
believes patients with normal-tension glaucoma have not only a
decrease in optic nerve blood flow but also an inherent abnormality in
the lamina, such as defective elastin, which predisposes the lamina to
excavation at intraocular pressures that are considered
"normal".
Some of the most exciting trends in glaucoma research have evolved
in the field of genetics. The talk given by Dr. Wallace (Lee) Alward
explained how new discoveries concerning the genetic basis of glaucoma
may redefine our understanding of the disease. Although much has been
learned about the glaucomas over the last hundred years, our current
classification system remains primarily descriptive. However, diseases
with different phenotypic appearances may nevertheless have the same
genetic basis. For example, Peters' anomaly and aniridia have both
been localized to the PAX6 gene on chromosome 11p. Both syndromes are
associated with glaucoma, and although their clincial appearances
differ, they may merely represent different mutations of the same
gene. Some forms of Rieger's anomaly and iris hypoplasia have been
localized to chromosome 4q. Although Peters' and Rieger's anomalies
were once classified together, a genetically based classification
system would assign them different etiologies given their location on
different chromosomes. Furthermore, some types of idiopathic (primary)
open-angle glaucoma and juvenile open-angle glaucoma have been
localized to Chromosome 1q. If other genes are discovered, we may find
that idiopathic open-angle glaucoma is not one disease but a similar
end result of many different genetic defects. When the products of
normal and defective genes are compared, we may better understand the
molecular etiologies of the glaucomas and provide more specific and
possibly curative therapies.
The end of the morning session was highlighted by the Becker
lecture given by Dr. Allan Kolker. Dr. Kolker first reviewed the
accomplishments of Dr. Bernard Becker and the profound influence he
has had on many of today's leading glaucomatologists. He then
described the evolution of glaucoma filtration surgery which remains
essentially a ‘plumbing operation’. Early filtration surgery
consisted of full-thickness sceral excision, performed with crude
instruments under low magnification, and, although it had a relatively
high success rate, there was also an unacceptably high rate of
complications, including flat anterior chambers and endophthalmitis.
Guarded filtration procedures, such as trabeculectomy, evolved a
generation ago, improving the complication rate, but also lowering the
success rate. The advent of microsurgery and, later, antifibrotic
agents, releasable sutures, and postoperative laser suture lysis, has
markedly increased the success rate of filtration surgery while
reducing such complications as flat anterior chamber and early
postoperative endophthalmitis to an all-time low. 5-Fluorouracil
temporarily inhibits fibroblast DNA synthesis by competitively
inhibiting thymidylate synthetase, while mitomycin-C is an alkylating
agent which permanently crosslinks DNA. Use of these agents leads to
thin, ischemic filtration blebs which are prone to leakage, and
leaking blebs can cause hypotony and late bleb-related endopthalmitis.
Thus far, the rate of complications with antifibrotic agents has been
far below that of full thickness procedures. However, because of their
relatively recent introduction, the long term incidence remains
uncertain. These drugs have brought guarded filtration surgery around
full circle to equal the success of full-thickness procedures, but
hopefully the complication rate will remain at an acceptable level.
The afternoon session addressed advances in "secondary"
glaucomas, such as pigment dispersion syndrome and neovascular
glaucoma, and reviewed medical and surgical therapy. In summary, the
glaucoma symposium presented a stimulating, comprehensive review of
the current trends in glaucoma management. It will be available
through the Academy on CD-ROM.
[ About NYGRI ][ Education ][ Glaucoma Network ]
[ How You Can Help ][ Question Corner ][ Research ]
|